I was really excited to try Allegory after hearing so many great things and reading all the hype on the review. The place itself is very cute, and I appreciate that they use fresh ingredients straight from the farm—that’s something I always support.
I ordered the Dad Bob burger with fries. It did taste fresh and somewhat healthy, but to be honest, it didn’t quite meet my expectations. The flavor wasn’t as satisfying as other burger spots I’ve tried, and the presentation was a bit messy—not really my style.
One thing I did enjoy was the cocktail I ordered—it was well made and had a great balance of flavor.
Unfortunately, what really ruined the experience for me was the service. My server was not attentive at all. I waited over fifteen minutes after I was clearly done eating, and no one came to check on me. I had to flag down another staff member just to get my check from my server, and even then, it took a while for my server to finally check on my table. I couldn’t help but feel uncomfortable, especially since I noticed the server was checking on all the other (white) customers around me but seemed to completely ignore my table. I truly hope it wasn’t racially motivated, but the difference in service was hard to ignore.
All in all, while the concept is nice and the drink was good, I personally wouldn’t return. The experience just didn’t live up to the reviews or what I had hoped for.
Don Dennis
-
June 30, 2025
Very nice restaurant. Farm to table. The tacos were very flavorful. I really enjoyed the nonalcoholic drink menu. I liked the soda shop fizz it was sweet and refreshing. The staff were very friendly and the food came out very quickly. Definitely will eat here again in the future.
Robert Seida
-
July 10, 2025
Allegory delivers on flavor and presentation. The short ribs were tender, well glazed, and plated with care. Everyone at our table enjoyed their dishes, and portions were generous without being overwhelming.
The cocktail list is short but well thought out. The rye with tobacco bitters had real depth, while the lighter spritzers offered a refreshing contrast. Each drink felt considered rather than just thrown on the menu.
We did try the charcuterie board, but it was underwhelming. There was too much bread and fruit, not enough meat, and it lacked the balance you expect from a board at this price point.
The space is tight and definitely loud, but it never crossed into unpleasant. The energy of the room added to the experience, and we had no problem keeping up a conversation. Worth visiting if you want a memorable meal with solid cocktails and don't mind a lively setting.
N S
-
August 28, 2025
Wow this was a hidden gem! Tried this place out for the first time today and was amazed at how good it was
The shrimp and grits and the pork belly sliders are a must try
Also the chicken and waffles was probably one of the best I’ve had in a long time they have a maple butter and the waffles keep some of their crisp even after a while
Victoria Joseph
-
August 20, 2025
This is one of my absolute favorite restaurants in Naperville! I've been here 3x now with friends and everytime the food (mine and theirs) was a hit and the service and atmosphere was great. I'll be back for more! You can't go wrong with this place.
Our Address
224 S Main St, Naperville, IL 60540, USA
Claim Listing: Allegory
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I was really excited to try Allegory after hearing so many great things and reading all the hype on the review. The place itself is very cute, and I appreciate that they use fresh ingredients straight from the farm—that’s something I always support. I ordered the Dad Bob burger with fries. It did taste fresh and somewhat healthy, but to be honest, it didn’t quite meet my expectations. The flavor wasn’t as satisfying as other burger spots I’ve tried, and the presentation was a bit messy—not really my style. One thing I did enjoy was the cocktail I ordered—it was well made and had a great balance of flavor. Unfortunately, what really ruined the experience for me was the service. My server was not attentive at all. I waited over fifteen minutes after I was clearly done eating, and no one came to check on me. I had to flag down another staff member just to get my check from my server, and even then, it took a while for my server to finally check on my table. I couldn’t help but feel uncomfortable, especially since I noticed the server was checking on all the other (white) customers around me but seemed to completely ignore my table. I truly hope it wasn’t racially motivated, but the difference in service was hard to ignore. All in all, while the concept is nice and the drink was good, I personally wouldn’t return. The experience just didn’t live up to the reviews or what I had hoped for.
Very nice restaurant. Farm to table. The tacos were very flavorful. I really enjoyed the nonalcoholic drink menu. I liked the soda shop fizz it was sweet and refreshing. The staff were very friendly and the food came out very quickly. Definitely will eat here again in the future.
Allegory delivers on flavor and presentation. The short ribs were tender, well glazed, and plated with care. Everyone at our table enjoyed their dishes, and portions were generous without being overwhelming. The cocktail list is short but well thought out. The rye with tobacco bitters had real depth, while the lighter spritzers offered a refreshing contrast. Each drink felt considered rather than just thrown on the menu. We did try the charcuterie board, but it was underwhelming. There was too much bread and fruit, not enough meat, and it lacked the balance you expect from a board at this price point. The space is tight and definitely loud, but it never crossed into unpleasant. The energy of the room added to the experience, and we had no problem keeping up a conversation. Worth visiting if you want a memorable meal with solid cocktails and don't mind a lively setting.
Wow this was a hidden gem! Tried this place out for the first time today and was amazed at how good it was The shrimp and grits and the pork belly sliders are a must try Also the chicken and waffles was probably one of the best I’ve had in a long time they have a maple butter and the waffles keep some of their crisp even after a while
This is one of my absolute favorite restaurants in Naperville! I've been here 3x now with friends and everytime the food (mine and theirs) was a hit and the service and atmosphere was great. I'll be back for more! You can't go wrong with this place.